Volume 11: Cornwall

Select a site alphabetically from the choices shown in the box below. Alternatively, browse sculptural examples using the Forward/Back buttons.

Chapters for this volume, along with copies of original in-text images, are available here.

Current Display: St Just-in-Penwith 1, Cornwall Forward button Back button
Overview
Present Location
Inside St Just's church: built into inside of north wall of north chancel aisle, where it is used as a lintel for an opening in the wall.
Evidence for Discovery
First recorded in 1868 in present location (Polsue 1868, 290). Probably found after 1842 since not mentioned by Buller (1842); possibly found in restoration of 1866 (see Peter, T. 1899–1900, 185). Portion of stone cut away by architect 'because it projected across the window arch' (Peter, T. 1899–1900, 188).
Church Dedication
St Just
Present Condition
Monument broken but stable; ornament clear; situation good
Description

Part of the rectangular shaft of a cross with only two faces visible.

A (broad): The surviving section of the shaft has an incised edge-moulding and is divided into two panels. The upper panel contains an irregular and unidentified six-strand interlace pattern, executed with well-modelled, rounded strands. The lower half of this panel contains rows of holes, either marking out the grid for an unfinished pattern or the result of trimming back the stone for later re-use. In the square lower panel are two concentric circular rings interlaced with two oval rings placed cross-wise (closed circuit pattern B). There is no carving beneath this, either because the shaft is unfinished or because this is the bottom of the shaft. If the latter, which seems most likely since the shaft appears to narrow slightly here, there appears to have been no tenon and the plain lower part of the shaft would have been sunk directly into the ground or into a base.

B (narrow) and C (broad): Not visible

D (narrow): The only decoration visible on this side is a short length of an incised edge-moulding at the top of the fragment and a small portion of unfinished or highly mutilated interlace of uncertain type.

Discussion

The exclusive use of single-strand interlace in panels distinguishes this cross-shaft from other pre-Norman sculpture in Penwith. Its closest parallels are instead with the crosses of the Panelled Interlace group in east Cornwall (Chapter IX, p. 85). In particular the ring-knot and the use of apparently unusual and irregular interlace can be compared with St Neot 1 (Ills. 151–4). The Doniert Stone (St Cleer 2, Ills. 51–4), arguably the earliest member of this group, is dated to the late ninth century or early tenth century. However a slightly later date is suggested for the St Just shaft because its remoteness, both in Cornwall and from other members of the group, suggests that it may be derivative. Equally, the competence of this piece compared with other pre-Norman sculpture in west Cornwall indicates that it belongs to a different tradition and is likely to be earlier than these.

The existence of this monument in the far west of Cornwall, remote from other members of the Panelled Interlace group, is difficult to explain. The site's early origin is indicated by a place-name in *lann and a sixth- to eighth-century inscribed stone with chi-rho (Okasha 1993, 243–7; Thomas, A. C. 1994, 286–7, 295). In the later medieval period it was believed to have possessed relics of its patron saint (Padel 1988, 100–1; Padel 2002, 355). All these factors may point to an early religious house of local importance in the far west of Cornwall, but do not explain the apparent connection with east Cornwall.

Date
First half of the tenth century
References
Polsue 1868, 290; (—) 1880–4, 18–19; Sedding, J. 1887, 446; Langdon, Arthur and Allen, J. R. 1888, 319, 325; Ranken 1888–92, 313; Langdon, Arthur 1889a, 319, 339, 343 and fig.; Langdon, Arthur 1890–1, 36, 38, 53, 61, 92 and fig.; Borlase, W. C. 1893, 184; Langdon, Arthur 1896, 23, 404–5, passim and fig.; Peter, T. 1899–1900, 187–8 and fig.; Daniell 1906, 456; Langdon, Arthur 1906, 438, 441; Sedding, E. 1909, 171; Henderson, C. 1925, 114; Hencken 1932, 271; Dexter and Dexter 1938, 223, 226, 261–2, 266, 268 and fig.; Henderson, C. 1957–60a, 242; Russell 1958–9, 101; Vosper 1964, 262; Nicholas 1968, 29; Pevsner 1970, 183; Russell 1971, 85; Rowe, L. 1973, fig.; Pearce 1978, 178; Langdon, Andrew 1997, 24, 38, no. 25, and fig.; Henderson, M. unpub. 1985, pp. 498–9, entry 249, and fig.; Manser unpub. 1987, 5; Jasper undated, no page numbering
Endnotes

Forward button Back button
mouseover