Volume 11: Cornwall

Select a site alphabetically from the choices shown in the box below. Alternatively, browse sculptural examples using the Forward/Back buttons.

Chapters for this volume, along with copies of original in-text images, are available here.

Current Display: Wendron 5 (Nine Maidens Down), Cornwall Forward button Back button
Overview
Present Location
In grounds of Clowance Country Club, Praze-an-Beeble, Crowan (SW 6336 3490)
Evidence for Discovery
First recorded in 1890–91 'at Clowance, Crowan' (Langdon, Arthur 1890–1, 67), presumably in or near present location. In 1830s standing at north-west corner of Nine Maidens' Down; in 1860s recorded in use as a gate-post at Hangman Barrow, Crowan, before being moved to Clowance Park and placed in a base c. 1883 (Langdon, Arthur 1896, 329–30). Recorded as fallen down in 1954 (Henderson, M. unpub. 1985, entry 169, p. 324); reerected 1989 (Langdon, Andrew 1993, 246–7)
Church Dedication
Present Condition
Monument broken but stable; ornament worn, some lichen; situation fair
Description

Round-headed cross with shaft of rectangular section, set in a modern base. On the front and back of the shaft are various incised motifs.

A (broad): On the head is an incised edge-moulding. Within this is a cross with arms only slightly expanded at the ends, formed by sinking four triangular areas. At the centre is a small hollow. Decoration on the top half of the shaft comprises five parallel incised vertical lines and, superimposed on these, two asymmetrical lines of sunken triangles, their points towards the middle. All the vertical incised lines, except the outer left and the central ones, terminate on top of the next pattern, which consists of two back to back semi-circles each formed of four concentric lines. The outer left vertical incised line ends at the bottom of the semi-circular motif; the central incised line runs down between the two semi-circles to terminate on a small circle. Immediately below this is an incised hour-glass or chalice motif. The lower part of the shaft is plain.

B and D (narrow): No trace of any ornament

C (broad): On the head is a cross formed by four incised triangles, their inner angles linked by diagonal lines. On the shaft, two incised lines run part way down the edge on the right-hand side, one on the left. The bottom edge of the head is continued by a curved incised line and hanging from this is an incised hour-glass or chalice. Further incised markings on the shaft may represent the worn remains of a chevron pattern, beneath which is a small circle and below it a larger one, about half way down the shaft.

Discussion

Appendix D item (continuing tradition)

This cross is one of a small group in the Carnmenellis granite area bearing a simple geometric cross on the round (wheel) head and characterised by chevrons or zig-zags and other incised patterns on the shaft (p. 107). The crosses in this group do duty as boundary stones and wayside crosses or mark chapel sites but none are associated with parish church sites.

The form of the cross on face A compares with one on a grave-slab from Calverley, Yorkshire, dated to the eleventh or twelfth century by Ryder (1991, 17). The incised triangles are reminiscent of Romanesque zig-zag work as seen, for example, on the Carnmenellis font (originally from Sithney: Sedding, E. 1909, 53–4, pl. XX). Incised concentric circles are seen on the Cuby font, dated by Sedding as late Norman (Sedding, E. 1909, 80–1, pl. XXXII). The hour-glass motif can be compared with the chalices incised on medieval grave-slabs and, if this interpretation is correct, the circle above the motif on face A may represent a communion wafer. However the chalices seen on grave-slabs are normally more ornate, with a knop on the stem: see examples in Ryder 2005, 54–5. Thus although Thomas suggested that this may be a pre-Norman monument (Thomas, A. C. 1967a, 90), the range of decorative motifs and the shape of the cross on the head combine to indicate a post-Norman Conquest date.

Langdon's description of the original location of the cross shows that it functioned both as a wayside cross, marking a cross-roads, and as a parish boundary stone. It stood 'on the greensward, by four cross-roads, at the north-west corner of Nine Maidens' Down, which is the meeting-point of the four following parishes: Illogan, Camborne, Crowan, and St. Wendron' (Langdon, Arthur 1896, 329). This cross is recorded under Wendron, since this is the parish in which the majority of crosses in this group are found; however it might equally have been recorded as belonging to any of the other three parishes.

Date
Twelfth century
References
Langdon, Arthur 1890–1, 62, 67–8, 70–3, 78, 80–1, 83; Langdon, Arthur 1896, 22, 294, 328–30, passim and figs.; Langdon, Arthur 1906, 438; Dexter and Dexter 1938, 142, 152 and figs.; Doble 1939a, 6; Henderson, C. 1957–60b, 480–1; Thomas, A. C. 1967a, 90; Wells 1976, 93; Langdon, Andrew 1993, 246–7 and fig.; Langdon, Andrew 1996a, 25; Langdon, Andrew 1999, 26, no. 31, and fig.; Henderson, M. unpub. 1985, entry 169, pp. 324–5 and figs.
Endnotes

Forward button Back button
mouseover